2026 / Cloud seeding & rain

Bias-Adjusted Attribution Estimation for Rainfall Enhancement Trials

arXiv · preprint

Open arXiv preprint ↗
SCOPED EVIDENCE NOTE
Preprint · 2607.21991v1

This record describes the specified arXiv version, not a journal publication. Weatherhill’s evidence note is a bounded source check and does not imply peer review. Subsequent versions may change the analysis.

What this source contributes.

The 2026 reanalysis estimates 6.68% attribution, compared with 12.52% from the earlier estimator applied within the same analysis. Point estimate 6.68%; bootstrap 95% interval 2.21–12.88%. Both estimators indicate a positive effect under the model. Table 3 separately lists a 7.36% bootstrap mean for the new estimator. Limit: A preprint reanalysis with overlapping authorship, not an independent trial or a guaranteed regional gain. Spatial dependence and model misspecification remain open sensitivity questions.

Scope of our check
selected main text and tables. Trial definition in Section 2, attribution discussion, Section 5, Table 3 and discussion of limitations. Numerical tables visually checked; derivation and simulation code not independently validated. Historical trial data not independently reanalyzed; spatial dependence and model misspecification remain limitations discussed by the authors. Review date: 2026-10-13. AI-assisted source check; not independent replication.

Read the connected Atlas case →

Primary material consulted

  1. Primary source 1

This is a bounded reading note. It is not independent replication, a full systematic review or an endorsement of every conclusion in the paper.

Questions to take to the paper

  • Was allocation randomized, and was the analysis specified first?
  • What cloud and weather regime was eligible?
  • Is the claimed change a local event, a seasonal total or a model estimate?
Keep the evidence attached to its setting.
A simulation, chamber result, field observation and operational outcome answer different questions. Record the comparator, measured quantity and conditions before carrying a result into a design.

Bibliographic provenance

Identifier, authors, title, posting date and version checked 2026-10-11 against the original arXiv repository record. The DOI field is intentionally empty. This preprint is kept distinct from any later journal version.

Continue in this field.

Search weatherhill

Search papers, tools and the project.