This record describes the specified arXiv version, not a journal publication. Weatherhill’s evidence note is a bounded source check and does not imply peer review. Subsequent versions may change the analysis.
What this source contributes.
The 2026 reanalysis estimates 6.68% attribution, compared with 12.52% from the earlier estimator applied within the same analysis. Point estimate 6.68%; bootstrap 95% interval 2.21–12.88%. Both estimators indicate a positive effect under the model. Table 3 separately lists a 7.36% bootstrap mean for the new estimator. Limit: A preprint reanalysis with overlapping authorship, not an independent trial or a guaranteed regional gain. Spatial dependence and model misspecification remain open sensitivity questions.
selected main text and tables. Trial definition in Section 2, attribution discussion, Section 5, Table 3 and discussion of limitations. Numerical tables visually checked; derivation and simulation code not independently validated. Historical trial data not independently reanalyzed; spatial dependence and model misspecification remain limitations discussed by the authors. Review date: 2026-10-13. AI-assisted source check; not independent replication.
Read the connected Atlas case →
Primary material consulted
This is a bounded reading note. It is not independent replication, a full systematic review or an endorsement of every conclusion in the paper.
Questions to take to the paper
- Was allocation randomized, and was the analysis specified first?
- What cloud and weather regime was eligible?
- Is the claimed change a local event, a seasonal total or a model estimate?
A simulation, chamber result, field observation and operational outcome answer different questions. Record the comparator, measured quantity and conditions before carrying a result into a design.
Bibliographic provenance
Identifier, authors, title, posting date and version checked 2026-10-11 against the original arXiv repository record. The DOI field is intentionally empty. This preprint is kept distinct from any later journal version.